Maybe this shouldn't be decided by coaches; maybe by an unbiased committee. You turn in your wrestlers information (where track wrestling should be inplace!). Wrestlers are awarded say points for A,B,C,D status and state placings. It is only fair that an A wrestler see's some benefit from that status; eventhough maybe his record doesn't show it. We all know it is a lot different to wrestle A wrestlers all day, then C and D wrestlers all day! Head to head competition is hard to included when some wrestlers are not seen in a bracket all season, before showing up in the sub brackets.
If a coach isn't at the meeting, his information (or letter) should have been disreguarded! Especially, if proven untrue.