Mr. Gentzler,
It's nice to see you respond to this post. I have 3 things. 1) Noah does cut weight for big tournaments, but most of the elite wrestlers do. Your son maybe a exception to the rule, I don't know, I can only go by what your saying and I'll give you the benefit of the doubt. And for the record, my son doesn't cut weight for ANY reason. Anybody who knows me will tell you that my son will take his wins or losses at his natural weight. 2) As far as Noah wrestling 58# division, he also does that for the competition just like your son does. I've even seen Noah wrestle 60# and wrestle 10u and 12u for tougher competition. If Noah doesn't cut weight, he should be wrestling at 55#. 3) Please don't bring up last year's matches, they don't have anything to do with this season.

As far as how big Noah looked compared to Zac, that's not even an issue. Because when Noah or Zac wrestles up a weight class, those kids are bigger than both boys and they still manage to win. You can't have it both ways, saying that my son wrestles up for competition and wins but when he loses to a bigger kid use that as an excuse, the kid is bigger.