I don't think you're giving Sparr enough credit. He gave Slyter a very tough match last year in the state semi finals but came up short. I would agree that before this years semis that beating Slyter would be bigger than beating Sparr, BUT Sparr knocked off Slyter in the semis this year making my argument that they are both high caliber wrestlers. Another reason I would give it to Cokeley is because 3 of his matches were against state placers, 2 of whom beat Slyter.