285 - Will Geary over Nathan Butler 4-3
@ Rocky Mountain Nationals 03/18/2012

285 - Nathan Butler(K) dec over Will Geary 4-0, 1-1
@ Wrestling Central Freestyle Duals 05/19/2012

Both 2012 high school 6A state champions Butler @220 and Geary @ 285.
Butler
2012 ASICS FILA freestyle National Champion @ 275
2012 ASICS FILA Greco National Runner-up @ 275.
2012 ASICS/USAW Folkstyle Nationals 3rd place @ 285

So a 1 point victory in folkstyle supersedes not only a pretty impressive freestyle victory but also all of Butler's National accomplishments?
Is Butlers #2 ranking simply because he was 220 last year and Geary was 285? Seems to me that Butler has had more National success and has faced better competition.
Using the 5 factors you listed at the top of this thread,
1. is a tie
2,3,5 go to Butler.