I think the fantasy team should be wrestlers at their high school ability level, for that's all we Kansans are familiar with for some of them.
In which case, Beltran gets the boot, as does Speer. (Not that they weren't great wrestlers.) I give Coleman the JV 171 spot, as he was a national champ in high school, and Boyle the top heavy spot by about 123123987523451063 votes.