You can not make rules to make kids or parents seek excellance. It would be great, in fact perferred if all high school state placers chose to wrestle in the high school division. It would be great if we could legislate that people have to become the best that they can. Such things can not be legislated. When making rules you must make them based on things that are concrete (age, weight, ect...). Again you can not tell a wrestler that is successful he is to be held to a higher standard because of their success. What happens to the wrestler that loses in overtime and is eliminated one match short of placing in high school state? He can wrestle 14U but the kid that beat him in OT cannot? All this rule change would do is help those that red shirt. They would get an extra year in 14U most kids would not. Just food for thought.