I think the Beliot team in 84, Kapaun in 85 or 86 and the 96 Ark city teams were great and are at the top of my list. I was impressed with the Bishop Carroll team last year: 190 pts., five state champs and 10 medalists. They were one of the best teams I have seen.
Addendum: Part of the fun of these forums is to compare the uncomparable otherwise there would be very little to comment on and even less to read. How fun would that be?