I would chose a healthy lattimer over any wrestler in 189 or 215 that you named on the list even over speer and dyer, because when he was healthy he wasn't tested by any wrestler except against philip walker who is another great wrestler who would have won state over josh caroll that year if they didn't move down to 5a.

the top 215 wrestlers on that list are

1.Lattimer
2.Speer
3.Walker

they were all 3 great and dominant wrestlers