Coach Gibson,
Good post. You came to the group with a key ingredient to dispute resolution…a solution. This issue can be debated and fixed now or we will be sitting here arguing the same vague guidelines next year at this time. I really think this could work. However, I agree that the guidelines need to be set at the district or state level. If this type of system were voted in at the district or state meeting, my club would be the first to commit to following the rule. It may be hard to track but it is definitely measurable. Eligibility would become clear-cut.
Mark Stanley
Junior Viking Wrestling