I say that Grater is better because in my opinion he's better on his feet and he's more of a finesse wrestler. And in the matches that I have seen where two very good wrestlers face each other, the winner won because he's better on his feet. Once again no offense to Taplin, but he's a bruiser and I don't think a bruiser could beat someone like Danny Grater.
To be something that you have never been, you must be willing to do something that you have never done.