I think you need to use the wrestlers senior weight to make this topic even worth discussing!
Luke was the 103lbs. state champ as a sophmore and then went on to win two more titles ending up at 125lbs. and I believe Tanner got fourth place at 103lbs. as a sophmore and then won 112lbs. as a junior and should win his last one at 119lbs. this year.
With that comparison I would have to take Luke.
I personally wanted to see Metzler and Hoover wrestle, I think Metzler would have won!