Under the rules of the cadet dual tournaments the All Star team is selected by adding up the classification points each wrestler earns during the tournament. The kid w/ the highest points at each weight is named the outstanding wrestler for that weight. You get 4 points for a pin, tech fall or forfeit. You get 3 points for a decision. The points you allow are not considered. If I added everything up then under this system Ely would have had 28 points while Clark had 30. It may have some flaws (ex: sitting out a match to allow the second stringer on your team wrestler someone will hurt you) but at least this system has a set criteria for picking the OW.